Thursday, February 23, 2017

I finished! But, why AP?

To be honest, the typical emotion I feel when I finish a book, whether it was middle school English class or Ap Literature, is similar to that of an everlasting goodbye.  When you think about it, you will never look through those character's eyes again, never hope for their survival, never disappoint over their ill-minded decisions.  I guess this is where the phrase "closing the book on someone" comes from.  Often after I finish reading a book, or more realistically a Netflix series, I just sit wherever I was, unsure about what to do with myself.  In my opinion, it really sucks to form a connection with a character, hope for them and watch them grow, just to reach the final pages and have to say goodbye.

All of these emotions last for about five minutes, then I'm back to checking Instagram.

I really do think that Cormac McCarthy ended The Road perfectly.  I was definitely expecting a grandiose gesture of human goodness (a thematic concept that I was banking on), but I never really was able to predict how I would feel about it.  The scene between the father and the son conclude epitomize the theme of human goodness, "goodness will find the little boy.  It always has.  It will again" (281).  Even though the father was talking about the boy that his son met earlier in the novel, it was clear that in his mind he meant his son, a boy who was born into a chaotic world but still shined with goodness.  As for the man that "rescued" (the term is used loosely because rescue insinuates salvation and also because we cannot be certain about the true intentions of the strange man), I think that that was a tough call for McCarthy to make.  Some readers may exclaim that it was a corny way to end a survival story, but would they have been satisfied with both the father and the son dying?  What does that say about God protecting the good, or the power of human goodness?  McCarthy's ending was a great way of 1) ending the depressing final scenes and 2) subtlely asserting one final bit of commentary on his thematic ideas.

Now for the big question, the one that has been lurking over me through my journey of blogging and exploring a novel on my own (for the most part).  Is Cormac McCarthy's novel, The Road, of AP merit?

Yes.

Why?  There are a few ways I can go about tackling this question.  I could compare The Road with the past novels I have read in AP Literature, those being Song of Solomon, Brave New World, The Handmaid's Tale, and Atonement.  While this is a logical method, is it not the unique qualities of a novel that make it transcendent across time as a masterpiece?  All novels of AP merit, in my opinion, must achieve the same, broad goal: skillfully use literary techniques supplemented with the plot to convey a social commentary pertaining to a relevant idea in society.  The means that are employed in order to achieve this goal are often unique to each other, and that is the beauty of literature.

The Road is of AP merit due to its vast collection of allusions, motifs, and symbolism that all connect to an overarching theme or meaning of the work.  The motif of dreams was evident in much of the novel's key scenes and was wrapped up incredibly.  "[Papa] fell into a dreamless sleep"; remember how I emphasized that dreams were Death's way of reaching out to people.  A dreamless sleep doesn't mean that Death has stopped chasing, it means that Death has found you.  This motif was related to the thematic concept of hope, and how maintaining hope but remaining realistic is the best remedy of survival.

McCarthy also connects allusions to his thematic ideas.  For example, the allusion to the Greek myth of Phaeton (explained in previous blog post) and the theme of human goodness's empowering property.  McCarthy used this allusion to elaborate on his ideas of human goodness as portrayed by the relationship and values of Papa and his son.  This novel is of AP merit because he deliberately uses complex literary devices to convey the meaning of the work as a whole.

Another facet of the novel that I believe highlights its worthiness of AP merit is the subtlety of Cormac McCarthy's own ideas within the novel.  He disguised his own values in the novel through the dialogue and thoughts of Papa and the boy.  He used this method to share his ideas on spirituality and morals and their respective fluctuations in a time of severe crisis.  This is a strong indicator of the novels complex underlying meanings and uniqueness.

All in all, The Road is an AP worthy novel as demonstrated by Cormac McCarthy's ability to connect literary devices to multiple themes and employ his own commentary into the novel discussing relative social controversies.  

5 comments:

  1. Cam, I like how you considered not just the themes and ideas that your author was trying to get across, but you also talked about how the literary devices connected back to the themes that you had mentioned. I agree with you on the idea that its those connections that are what makes a book AP.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Cam, I agree with you and agree that the book was ended very well. There was a buildup for the death of somebody and McCarthy rounded it up in a satisfying way. Also, I agree with the novel being AP worthy, but how do you think you could use it on an AP test? Do you think large classes could have educated discussions about this novel?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's interesting that you bring up the potential for class discussion and after some thought, I guess it really wouldn't be the best novel for a class seminar or something of that nature. This has definitely been a book that is better explored alone or in small groups because of its uniqueness. If it were in a larger group, I think that there would significantly less individual analysis of McCarthy's style and its relation to the novel's big ideas.

      Delete
  3. Cam, you do a nice job opening your posts and using the openings to lead into your discussion. I often feel the same way, and my response to the end of a book is often what determines whether I find a book powerful or not. If I keep thinking about the characters, then the book has a powerful meaning. Do you think this ending is one that will linger in your mind?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm sure that the meaning behind the ending will linger, not so much what actually happened. In "Song of Solomon", I really don't remember the ending that well and I never fully understood it, so I think because I was able to draw meaning out of the ending to "The Road", it will hang around for a bit.

      Delete